The congregation held its first congregational meeting on October 26, 1914. The German English Evangelical St. Paul’s Congregation officially adopted a German constitution on January 28, 1915 with missions being one of the first objectives. In 1918, they trialed the envelope system for offerings which is still in use today as well as started using individual cups for communion. Due to the pressure of WWI, an English constitution was adopted in 1918. The services also started to incorporate more English. A short English sermonette was given at 9:30 on Sunday mornings with a full German service at 10:45.
As the church body continued to grow, it was determined that a Christian day school was needed.
St. Paul’s Luther School was established in 1915.
The 1930s brought the Great Depression and the Dust Bowl. Like many others around the country times were tough. To keep the church afloat, the parsonage at 7th and High was sold and the pastor was given $33 a month as a rental allowance.